'The greater the challenge, the greater the merit'
And so we set off for Tibet. Within an hour, a call from our
airline, Etihad, suggested we abort our itinerary due to the 25 April
earthquake in Nepal, the epicentre just west of our first port of call,
Kathmandu.
But we persisted, our passage through Kathmandu critical as this
was key to obtaining the all-important entry visa into Tibet. Flying via Abu
Dhabi, the omens seemed against us once more as we were held in a stack south
east of Kathmandu due to a major thunderstorm. Eventually landed, swiftly through
immigration, we then endured a one and a half hour wait to collect baggage, the
issue almost certainly shortage of staff due to the earthquake. Exiting into a
chaotic Arrivals hall, we were soon to discover that our transfer agent wasn't
there for us, Etihad having cancelled our scheduled flight from Abu Dhabi and
having put us on a slightly later one.
Our group, facing the prospect of a damp, cold night in the
frenetic entrance lobby seemed remarkably stoic, an attribute that was to be
called upon many more times in this increasingly challenging adventure. But
then, after many attempts, we were able to secure hotel accommodation for the
night, the Shangri La, in Lazimpal, just north of the city centre. The next
challenge was to find a couple of taxis, only achieved by grim determination
and lots of US dollars in the face of stiff competition.
Phew!
So, what a start!
The next day we hooked up with our apologetic agent, toured a
little of the northern outskirts of the city, pulling in quick visits to
Boudhanath, Swayambunath and the hybrid Buddhist/Hindu temple of
Budhanilkantha, all deserted of the usual tourist throng, and locals having
shut up business for the next few days. More noticeable were the many
encampments springing up everywhere, people fearful of returning to their
homes.
Our entry visa duly issued, we readied ourselves for an early
flight to Lhasa the next morning, although news later emerged that this flight
was probably going to be cancelled and our only option then was to transit via
Chengdu. Yet another challenge.
Predictably, Kathmandu departures was a melee of visitors anxious
to get out of Nepal, notably Chinese citizens in the Chengdu queue next to
ours, tempers rising to a noisy crescendo. Surprisingly, we were checked in for
Lhasa, but then the real wait began, some eight hours or so, as all commercial
traffic was, quite rightly, rescheduled to accommodate huge military transports
from China, USA, Israel and other nations bringing in much needed aid.
|
The Superpowers bring aid to Kathmandu |
Doubts increased during the afternoon as to whether we'd ever get
to Lhasa, when suddenly, late afternoon, we were boarded on our Air China
flight.
But we never got to Lhasa.
Another challenge. We were going to Chengdu, a three hour flight,
and would be accommodated in a hotel for a few hours before taking an early
morning flight to Lhasa. This unscheduled excursion did end in success,
however.
Emerging into the early morning air of Gongkar airport, an hour
south of Lhasa, having enjoyed the spectacle of the mountain terrain west of
Chengdu, we were now in the hands of our Tibetan agents, and our adventure
could begin in earnest.
Or so we thought. It quickly became apparent that the Nepalese
earthquake had affected the Everest and Shishapangma regions of south-west
Tibet, and that our itinerary was going to have to change.
Now, from this point onwards, this account is going to differ
from my usual format. Because, this blog is about challenges. And if you have
romantic notions about travelling through this vast area I might as well spell
them all out at the beginning.
Tibet, as you may well know, was invaded by the Chinese between
1950 and 1959, and the hapless citizens were then exposed to the worst excesses
of the Cultural Revolution, leading many to go into exile, and for everyone
across both China and Tibet, untold suffering. Tibet, of course, was always
going to be vulnerable to the expansionist policies of its closest neighbour,
and the theocracy that had ruled the country for centuries had isolated itself
from the international arena and the modernisation that had inevitably followed
the Industrial Revolution. Tibetans lived a mediaeval existence, primarily
engaged in the production of barley, the staple diet for centuries, and the
raising of yak, sheep and goats for milk, curd, cheese, meat and skins.
Infrastructure was rudimentary and the key activity of the common people was to
support the monasteries and the aristocracy who ruled the country.
So Mao had an easy target, and the legacy of the Chinese invasion
is all too plain to see right up to the present day.
Of course, there are positives. Given the high altitude terrain
and the persistence of snow on the highlands for much of the year, Tibet now
has an impressive road network, world beating telecommunications and internet
access (where else in the world can you get 3G on a remote 5000m pass?),
standardised education and health care. But there's a cost.
China does not like regional autonomy. It hates the West's
continued cry for human rights in Tibet. It abhors the so-called 'splittist'
activity of the Dalai Lama (a gentle soul loved throughout the international
arena, and himself accepting that there is no going back to an independent
Tibet). As a result the people of Tibet are amongst the most rigidly controlled
groups in the world. That's the price they have to pay for modernisation. A
deeply spiritual people, most seem to accept it with the resignation that you
would expect of a devout Buddhist - all things are impermanent, live as good a
life as you can in this one, and karma will transport you to a better existence
in the next life. But the control pervades every aspect of their existence -
freedom of movement between areas needing permits in many cases, little freedom
to travel abroad, the education system enforcing Chinese as the first language,
controls on the number of monks occupying monasteries, CCTV monitoring in the
major towns, and strong military presence almost everywhere.
|
Tibetans remain deeply religious people who live under the cloud of constant surveillance by the Chinese authorities |
And, as a visitor, you will get to feel how it is to be a local.
Don't dare bring a picture of the Dalai Lama into the country, or a Tibetan
flag. Don't even think of venturing to Tibet unaccompanied, as it is mandatory to
have a guide, and don't expect to wander at will. Our itinerary, which included
the western regions of Tibet, with a pilgrimage around Mount Kailas and an
exploration of the ancient Kingdom of Guge, required a standard visitors permit
for Lhasa, an 'alien's permit' for travel beyond Lhasa, and military clearance
to visit the western regions.
We were warned that in the towns, we could expect to be shadowed
by Chinese security services, to check we did not do or say anything that was
in contravention of their policy, not least don't dare talk about the Dalai
Lama. And when you get out on the road, don't expect to get anywhere fast.
Heading west from Lhasa to Shigatse, and then further west to the Ngari region,
a distance of some 1500km to our final destination of Tsaparang, a speed limit
of 40 kph is rigidly enforced. Regular police checkpoints require the driver to
produce his license, and a time of arrival is stamped on a permit, the elapsed
time at the next checkpoint then used to assess the average speed driven. Stiff
fines and penalty points are levied for contravention. 40kph. Absolutely
ridiculous. These are some of the emptiest roads on the planet.
|
West of Shigatse the roads empty, yet a speed limit of 40 kph is rigidly enforced |
Sorry to sound
cynical, but I rather suspect that this is just another technique to dissuade
visitors from venturing too far from the suspicious eyes of the Chinese
security services. And, of course, at other key checkpoints we were required to
present our (now invaluable) entry/exit permit and passports, together with the
relevant permit to travel, a process usually left to our indomitable guide, but
sometimes requiring us to be inspected by an army officer. Happily, they were
usually pleasant, but what a palaver. And, when in the more sensitive areas,
our presence was then recorded and monitored by the PSB, the Public Security
Bureau. We were even required to sign a disclaimer when entering Darchen, at
the base of Mount Kailas, ensuring that we did not hold the authorities
responsible if we were to succumb to some unfortunate event whilst
circumambulating Mount Kailas.
|
One of some twenty or so checkpoints we had to stop at on the 1500km journey from Lhasa to Guge in western Tibet |
Of course, don't let any of that put you off. A good local agent
and guide will see to most of this nonsense, but there's a few other things
that you might want to be aware of before you pack your bags. Tibetans have
never been known for their cleanliness. And local 'long drop' toilet facilities
are de rigeure, ubiquitous outside the main towns, and guesthouses will
usually have no internal facilities, residents having to rely on visits to an
outside block. I should also mention that these blocks have no private
cubicles. Instead a low wall separates one from your fellow human being, the
required position being to squat low and do one's business. If joined by a
local, expect an inquiring look/stare and clouds of cigarette smoke. Oh, and
that's for the ladies as well as the gents.
The facilities are rarely, if ever cleaned, and we found tons of
litter in some, snow drifts in another, and of course, previous deposits from
fellow humans with a poor aim. Lovely.
|
One of the better 'long-drop' toilets, this one with a fine view (at Tsaparang) |
I should also mention accommodation. Our hotels in Lhasa, Gyantse
and Shigatse were fine, although a consistent theme is one of dodgy plumbing.
Showers rarely work in the way they're intended, availability of hot water
variable, and flushes may not work effectively. There seems to be a singular
lack of plumbing skills in this region. But these places will seem like the
height of luxury once you've ventured further out and experienced the delights
of the Tibetan guesthouse. Some are fine, with genial hosts who rush to supply
you with a thermos of hot water on arrival and provide cold water for flushing
interior toilets. Well, I can think of one like that.
Most guest houses are far more basic. External toilets, usually
filthy and full of litter, are the norm, one memorable location in Tholing using
the adjacent public toilet. This meant that during the night you had the
pleasure of running the gauntlet of local dogs and random drunks emptying from
the music venue conveniently located nearby. And in the Kailas region the guest
house owners have cleverly exploited the recent ban on camping on the kora
around the mountain by charging for all of the beds in any one room, typically
four or five, even if it's occupied by just one person. So, be warned. Even in
the hotels beds rarely have much padding. Basically, it's like sleeping on a
brick. So, pack a Thermarest or equivalent mattress, and a silk liner with
sleeping bag are invaluable as there is no heating in guest houses (and hotels
are not much better).
|
Sensible use of a skip (!), seen on the final day of our kora around Kailas returning towards Darchen |
|
Guesthouse room in Tholing, one CCTV channel in English and mattress like a brick. That's OK, but the sanitation relied on the adjacent public toilet... The hosts were really nice though. |
Food is generally safe, and the best choice usually comes from
the Chinese community, our guide pointing to those previously used, and
presumably offering him a good incentive. But, there's an overall monotony once
you venture further afield. I suppose it says it all when most of the
population drink butter tea, 3% beer (Lhasa Beer or watered down Budweiser the
most commonly available) and enjoy a paste of roasted barley flour called
tsampa. You will initially enjoy momos, steamed or fried, noodles of various
persuasions, and egg fried rice. After a week you'll be dreaming of roast beef,
Yorkshire Puddings and real ale. Veggies, make up your own fantasy list.
And one last thing, if you've read this far. They're noisy
buggers. Every settlement, however small, has its own pack of dogs. Benign and
vaguely cuddly during the day, the packs assemble and roam at night, seeing who
can produce the most irritating bark for longest, whilst simultaneously
contesting leadership of the pack. Expect at least three circuits of your
accommodation per night. And then there's the local populace. They like to
party. Late. Almost every night of our journey, some inconsiderate jerk would
talk loudly outside our rooms, unless they were on a motorbike with a portable
stereo blaring away, or singing at the top of their tuneless voice in the local
karaoke bar. Yes, bring good earplugs. More important than your walking boots!
OK, I've vented my spleen. After three weeks of bureaucratic
frustration and uncertainty, nausea at the sight of another momo, and another
disturbed night, it's inevitable. But the rewards are HUGE.
Firstly, the people. Your first experience is likely to be the
elderly citizens who walk clockwise around the Barkhor, the circumambulation of
the revered Jokhang Temple in the old city of Lhasa. Their skin, heavily wrinkled
and darkened by years of exposure to the acutely high UV levels at this
altitude (Lhasa at 3650m being one of the lowest points of the Tibetan
plateau), their dress of heavy fabrics, ladies adorned with jewellery handed
down through the generations, prayer beads or prayer wheels in hand, with the
pervasive murmur of
Om Mani Pad Me Hum, the mantra which repeated many
thousands of times seems sure to give the practitioner hope of a better future
life. A simple smile or the standard Tibetan greeting '
Tashi Dalek'
(pronounced "tashi daley") will usually elicit a warm response, even
more so now as Western tourists are significantly outnumbered by Chinese, many
of whom now travel to Lhasa on the pressurised train from Beijing.
|
Friendly ladies at the teahouse adjacent to Drikung Thil |
Then there's the many monasteries and temples belonging to the
various sects of Tibetan Buddhism, each with different lineages and a
bewildering array of Buddhas, Bodhisattvas, meditational deities (called
yidams) and fearsome 'Protectors.' The artwork on the walls of the various temples,
some dating to the 11th century in the case of Tholing, is complex and
difficult to interpret to the non-practitioner but never ceases to interest and
amaze even the most indifferent of observer. Usually dimly lit with random
electric light bulbs and the ubiquitous butter lamps, the potentially austere
atmosphere is lifted by colourful silk banners, golden statutes of the main
deities, and torma offerings, sculpted coloured butter on a clay or tsampa
base. On several occasions we were able to witness monks in prayer sessions
and, in one, memorable, visit to Ganden, the principal monastery of the Gelukpa
order, we were able to observe their celebration of the auspicious fifteenth of
the lunar month. Chanting, led by the distinctive deep-throat chant of the
chief lama, was accompanied by the presentation of gifts of the white silk
scarves called khata, and other ritual offerings.
|
Monks celebrating an auspicious day in the Tibetan calendar, Ganden Monastery |
|
'Yellow Hat' monks of the Gelugpa order, Ganden |
|
Two of the 'Worldly Protectors' - Kumbum, Gyantse |
|
Wrathful deity, Kumbum, Gyantse |
And then there's the landscape. Tibet is a huge country,
occupying about one third of modern China's footprint. Most of it lies above
5000m, so acclimatisation in lower areas like Lhasa (at about 3650m) is
essential before one ventures far from the city. To give an example, travelling
from Saga to Guge, you will never be below 4500m, and on several passes you
will experience the thin air of 5000m+. We visited during May, so the main
passes were clear of snow, although on the highest ones there was a great deal
of snow banked up following the passage of snow ploughs. We experienced light
snow showers on a number of occasions, and when walking the three day kora
around Mount Kailas we spent most of day two carefully traversing slopes of
hard packed snow, great in the morning when it was firm, but requiring much
greater care in the afternoon as the intense heat of the sun caused the snow to
melt, some of our number sinking groin deep at times on the descent from the
5650m pass of Dromla La. Our guide said that the snow at this level would
normally have completely disappeared by July. But the snow gave the landscapes
we passed through an extra character, especially as much of Tibet's landscape
tends to have a ubiquitous brown hue.
|
On the approach to Drolma La, already over 5000m. Kailas' northern eastern face in the background |
|
Entering Zanda, from the road into Guge, western Tibet |
|
View to the Garhwal Himalaya of India, across the Sutlej canyon lands - from the road to Tholing (Tada) |
Travelling from Shigatse west to Kailas and Guge, a distance
greater than the latitudinal spread of Nepal, the sights are glorious, with the
bounding peaks of Sikkim and the Nepalese Himalaya filling the southern skyline
on many stretches, the most impressive that of the Gorakh Himal on the section
of high road from Drongpa to Lake Manasarovar. The distinctive snow dome of
Nanda Devi 7816m emerges on the horizon as you transit south from Montser. Even
further west, taking the new road from Bauer to Tholing in Guge, the peaks of
the Garhwal Himalaya reveal themselves above the spectacular rock formations of
the canyons formed by the Sutlej river as it winds its way down from its source
near Lake Manasarovar to eventually enter the mighty Indus River and eventually
the Arabian Sea.
|
Gurla Mandhata, 6694m, to the south of the sacred Lake Manasarovar |
Most of the time, the roads use wide
river valleys to make progress, bounded by endless hills and mountains of
weatherbeaten brown rock and soil, sometimes punctuated by patches of shrub,
crystal clear pools and small nomad encampments, usually with a herd of yak or
sheep nearby. This is an isolated life, fundamentally unchanged in centuries,
their small huts providing a year round base and yak skin tents their mobile
home to exploit summer pasture at higher levels. Some wildlife is also
occasionally seen on this barren plateau, not a tree in sight to provide cover.
On our visit we observed fox, wolf,
blue sheep, marmot type creatures known as mountain rats by the locals, small deer and wild ass.
|
Nonchalence from a wolf spotted en route from Saga to Darchen |
And vultures. On one of our
acclimatisation walks we were in the rare position to observe a sky burial.
Whilst taking a few hours to walk from Pabonka monastery to Chu Tsang nunnery
we passed above Lhasa's main sky burial site at a time when the body of a
deceased person was being crushed and cut up
ready for the vultures to devour. Still the predominant form of burial for
Tibetans, this was a rare and very humbling sight.
|
On the pilgrim's circuit from Pa Bong Kha monastery to Chu Tsang nunnery, having just witnessed a sky burial |
So what of our itinerary? In a break
from the usual format of my travel blogs, I'm not going to go into a day by day
detailed account, given that a trip of over three weeks would be tedious to
write, and too long for you to read.
Our early days in Tibet, initially a
team of six, were spent acclimatising around Lhasa, taking in the classic
sights of the huge Potala Palace, the Jokhang Temple and walking the Barkhor
around it, watching the monks in open debate at Sera Monastery and enjoying
the palaces of the Norbulingka summer palace park. We also made time to visit
the Ramoche temple, just north of the Barkhor.
From the time of our arrival in Tibet
there had been uncertainty about our ability to proceed westwards from Lhasa
due to earthquake damage in the area of New Tingri down to the Nepalese border
at Zhangmu, and the significant aid efforts by the Chinese military in the
region. It was clear that our plan to visit Everest Base Camp from Rongphu and
then to trek to the base camp of Shishapangma, the only 8000m peak wholly in
Tibet, would not be possible. One, for safety reasons, and, two, because the
authorities do not want foreigners seeing their internal problems, even though
the resettlement camps we observed in the vicinity of Lhartse were impressively
organised. Our guide told us that people relocated here from the earthquake
affected area immediately to the south had been told that they may be there for
up to two years whilst roads were reconstructed and homes rebuilt.
|
Resettlement camp for evacuees from the earthquake affected areas of Zhangmu and Nyalam |
Upon our return to Lhasa we were
delighted to find that we could advance a little further west, at least as far
as Shigatse. We travelled there via one of Tibet's most sacred lakes, the
beautiful turquoise Yamdrok Tso at an elevation of 4408m (the same height as
Mont Blanc) and then on to Gyantse, home of the famous dzong which was attacked
by the British in 1904, and the 15th century temple complex of Pelkor Chode and
the adjacent Kumbum, noted for its many chapels over nine storeys, together
containing ten thousand Buddha images. Onwards to Shigatse at 3869m, for the
best hotel yet and a visit to Tashilhumpo, a huge monastery complex once home
to the Panchen Lamas. This was a rather depressing visit, the temples closed to
visitors until late afternoon, and now devoid of its once large monk population
following government controls.
|
West from Lhasa |
|
Yamdrok Tso |
|
Hoping that the yak doesn't go into reverse... |
|
Looking west across Yamdrok Tso to Noching Kansang, 7138m |
Beyond Shigatse, the roads emptied and
we entered the mountainous void that lies beyond central Tibet. Many passes
were crossed, most well over 4500m, passing remote communities, range upon
range of mountains, many still snow-capped, until, after two days, we caught
our first sight of Gurla Mandhata, a 7728m peak close to the border at Hilsa in
northwest Nepal. This is a magnificent looking mountain, dominating the
southern end of the sacred lake Manasarovar, the 'Lake Conceived from the Mind
of God,' at an altitude of 4572m and one of the world's largest bodies of pure
water.
|
View to the Nepalese Himalaya, on the road west from Drongpa Tradun (Zhongba) |
|
Remnants of winter snow on many of the high passes crossed en route to the Kailas region |
|
Lake Manasarovar, still partially covered in ice, from Chiu monastery |
Our first sighting of Kailas was a
little more elusive, dark storm clouds banked over it in stark contrast to the
bright sunshine of late afternoon that was bathing the lake, still largely
covered in ice, and the glaciers of Gurla Mandhata. We ended up in the scruffy
little town of Darchen for the night, having first driven up a ridge bordering
the west side of the lake to check out accommodation near Chiu monastery. This
was subsequently rejected, and it was four very tired travellers who eventually
checked into the basic guest house at the bottom of the town, now at an
elevation of 4575m.
|
Pilgrims prostrating in respect to Mount Kailas, the abode of the buddha Demchok (Cakrasamvara) |
|
Snow showers, early evening over Kailas |
We decided to do the kora the following
morning as the weather dawned bright. The prospect of a good walk after many
days of travelling in the van was very inviting, so we headed off on the 52km
clockwise circuit of the mountain. This is an important pilgrimage for both
Hindus and Buddhists, and for followers of the ancient Bön religion, who do
the kora in the opposite direction. Walking the circuit is considered very
meritorious by followers of these religions, the merit greater with repeated
circumambulations and enhanced if completed in one day or, in the case of
Buddhists, with multiple prostrations on the way around. Whether the four of us
yielded any merit remains to be seen, but apart from a dozen or so Tibetans, we
had the trail to ourselves, a real privilege.
The first day is a relatively easy
22.5km walk up the valley bounding the west face of the mountain, first passing
Tarboche, the site of the annual Saga Dawa festival when a large pole festooned
with prayers flags is raised. It's verticality is said to determine the conditions
for Tibet in the coming year - if it is raised at a perfect perpendicular to
the ground, then conditions will be favourable. Beyond this the valley narrows,
the tiny monastery of Choku Gompa on the west side and the rock buttresses
either side of the valley dominating the view. Later, on the approach for the
first stopover, the monastery guesthouse of Driraphuk at 4950m, the trail winds
its way through a valley that trends eastwards, and it was here that snow banks
and frozen streams heralded different walking conditions for the following day.
|
Up bright and early to walk the sacred kora around Mount Kailas, from our guest house in Darchen |
|
Our two girl porters |
|
Looking back to Gurla Mandhata across the Barkha plain |
|
Into the canyon of Lha Chu, day one of the kora |
|
Tarboche, site of the annual Saga Dawa festival |
|
A deserted kora - we only saw a dozen Tibetans all day |
|
Frozen waterfalls on the western flanks of the Kailas massif - we assume the braiding was caused by strong winds.
Any other theories? |
|
Splendid isolation |
|
The western buttresses of Kailas |
|
Pilgrims on the final walk-in to Driraphuk monastery |
|
Chortens at Driraphuk, the Karma Kagyu monastery built around the 'cave of the female yak horns,' used by the sage Gotsangpo in the early 13th century for meditation |
Day two of the kora greeted us with
superb views to the north face of Kailas, a 1500m cliff face, and took us up
slopes of hardened snow, making for good progress over what would otherwise be
uneven ground, although we were now performing above 5000m, so a slow steady
pace was essential. Our big challenge today was to successfully cross the pass
of Drolma La at 5660m, the final approach up a steeper snow slope, and where we
were overtaken by two or three groups of young Tibetans who had a somewhat
faster pace than us! The whole team managed the pass, a 760m climb from our
start point, a great atmosphere prevailing there as elated youngsters fixed new
prayer flags to kick off the new pilgrimage season.
|
North face of Kailas from Driraphuk |
|
Team member Cadi on the final ascent |
|
Up, up and up in the thin air above 5000m...the elusive Drolma La still out of sight |
|
Ralph and Carole reach the Drolma La at 5660m |
|
Drolma La - one happy team! |
|
Young Tibetans refreshing prayer flags |
|
The only way is down...and quick about it before the snow softens too much |
But it was not a place to linger, one
for the debilitating effect of altitude, and two, because the sun was already
softening the snow, making the descent quite tricky in places, and in one spot,
a slope of blue water ice needed some concentration, and a little assistance
from our two girl porters. Working our way down a final rocky bluff, 400m lost
in an hour and a half, we then faced a very long valley plod to our guesthouse
at the tiny monastery of Dzultrulpuk which encloses a cave used by the famous
Buddhist mystic, Milarepa. This was a welcoming spot after a total distance
walked of 22.9km, the host family cheerful and friendly, and with the rooms
constructed from thin sheet metal, it was a chilled place to celebrate our
crossing of the Drolma La, both physically and metaphorically.
|
Descent from the Drolma La |
|
Care required on the blue ice below! |
|
Steep descent in places before reaching the wide valley of the Lham Chu |
|
The welcoming owners of the guest house at Zutrulphuk monastery - their living
accommodation and teahouse for passing pilgrims during the day |
|
Zutrulphuk moanstery, site of Milarepa's contest with the Bon deity Naro Boncheng |
The third day of
the kora is a straightforward downhill valley walk of 11.3km, a few rises just
to test your mettle, but easily despatched in a morning, a little entertainment
provided by a shepherdess controlling her flock with a slingshot and a passing
herd of yak.
|
Mind that yak! Day three on the kora, back to Darchen |
From Darchen, four happy adventurers
headed across the wide plain west of the lake of Rakas Tal, the objective to
reach the ancient kingdom of Gugé, established in the 10th century as
one of three western kingdoms (the others Ladakh and Purang), founded by
Buddhists fleeing persecution from king Langdarma who turned against Buddhism.
With the influence of two great Buddhist masters, the translator Rinchen
Zangpo, and the scholar Atisha, Guge was the focal point for the second
diffusion of Buddhism in Tibet, creating a more disciplined and scholarly
approach to enlightenment, and seeding the rise of the 'New Translation'
schools, starting with the Kadampa.
The legacies of this era are the 10th
century temples of Tholing, and the 15th century fortress/temple complex of
Tsaparang. But first we had to get to them. Turning left at Bauer, a marvellous
road, rising to 5200m at one point, took us through canyons of red, blue and
orange rock, before revealing views to the Garhwal Himalaya of Uttaranchal,
northern India, snow capped peaks lining the horizon as far as the eye can see.
But there was another surprise to come - the vast canyon lands of the Sutlej
river system, which unfolded before us as we descended to the town of Tholing,
the first capital of Gugé.
The highlight, though, was Tsaparang.
Apart from an early morning posse of army personnel wandering around as
sightseers, we had the place to ourselves (in fact we'd only seen two other
western visitors in the preceding six days). Situated on the side of a steep
sandstone canyon above the Sutlej river, there is a monastery complex of four
temples on the lower elevations, and a cleverly created walkway takes you up to
the citadel fortress, 170m above the entranceway, passing caves variously used
for accommodating the lower classes, meditation cells for monks, kitchens and a
prison. The views from here, in bright sunshine, were, quite simply,
unequalled.
But then, we had to head relentlessly
eastwards. More checkpoints, more stupid speed limits (and a convoy of Army
trucks bringing earthquake victims to resettlement camps), a nice guesthouse in
Saga followed by a more luxurious hotel in Shigatse, giving us all the
opportunity for the first hot shower in eight days. Bliss.
Final reflections
I leave Tibet with a tinge of regret.
I'm unlikely to return again, this my second visit, and feel that the continued
modernisation of this huge region will swamp what is left of the ancient ways.
The Chinese have made amazing improvements to the infrastructure and clearly
there is a great deal of wealth being generated in the urban areas, designer
clothes shops and BMW dealerships in Lhasa a testament to that. But one does
not have to venture far from Lhasa to see the other side of the coin - an
agrarian, subsistence economy where the traditional Tibetan population continue
to toil in the fields, using their own labour to dig irrigation ditches and sow
crops of barley, still using horse or yak drawn ploughs, and returning to small
houses enclosed by walls covered in yak dung drying in the sun for future fuel
needs.
Some monasteries still appear to have
some life left in them, but it was particularly noticeable that most of the
people either circumambulating them or queuing to give offerings of butter were
in the older age group, and that not once did we see young novice monks. Of
course, the monasteries are becoming a new money-spinner for the authorities
and old thangkas are now fashionable in the auction rooms of Beijing and
Shanghai, fetching ludicrously high prices, rather like the interest that
persists in artefacts of the Ming Dynasty.
Living in Tibet as a Tibetan must be
galling. Chinese is now the only language used in schools, there are tight
restrictions on movement, and various aspects of behaviour (for example, our
driver had to register his details every time petrol was purchased following
the high incidence of immolations by monks in the recent past). The speed
limits outside the cities are frustrating and the requirement to continually
show travel permits a major limitation on personal freedom and privacy.
Tibetans know that they are constantly monitored by undercover authorities and
the ubiquitous CCTV in urban areas.
The control on personal movement in the
country is a major challenge for all visitors to Tibet, and we were very lucky
to have achieved what we did, many fellow visitors stuck in the immediate
environs of Lhasa as the authorities over-reacted to continuing earth tremors
in Nepal. As our guide said, the rulings on permits change as often as the
weather.
And the Tibetans themselves do not make
it easy for westerners either. Hotels are adequate, but guesthouses, whilst
often characterful, are, for the most part, lacking in hygienic toilet facilities,
with plumbing rudimentary or completely absent in places. Littering is a
national disgrace, even on the sacred circuit around Kailas, and public toilets
demand a strong stomach. Food is generally fine, albeit rather monotonous if
one just sticks to Tibetan restaurants, and none of our group suffered from any
notable stomach upsets.
But, this is still a country that is
compelling to many, and justifiably so. The traditional Tibetans are amongst
the most devout and spiritual people on the planet, and the institutions of
Tibetan Buddhism are a marvel of artistic and metaphysical complexity, the
colours and sounds unique to this part of the world, with a history going back
to the 7th century when the Tibetan Kings were first exposed to Buddhism from
Nepal and China.
The landscapes of mountains, canyons
and vast tracts of high altitude desert are stupendous in scale and are majestic in
their barrenness and remoteness, criss-crossed by some still pursuing a nomadic
existence, herding yaks and sheep.
So, take your choice. Prepare for some
considerable challenges - the control by the authorities, the privations of
basic accommodation and quality of sanitation in remoter parts, and the long
distances involved. But also be prepared to have one of the most unique experiences
of your life - a glimpse into a mediaeval world of subsistence living and
devotion, gaining an introductory
insight into one of the most complex metaphysical systems on Earth, and
taking in the vast empty landscapes punctuated by some of the highest mountains
in the world, ultimately the source of four great Asian rivers.
Like so many other regions of the
world, the relentless modernisation of society, with enviable
telecommunications, audacious infrastructure projects and the rise of western
materialism in the younger echelons of society, will swamp traditional ways of
life, the spiritual aspects becoming a curio and the increasing polarisation of
the people into the urban rich and rural poor. But, haven't we seen this all
before...?
Finally, my thanks to a fine bunch of travelling companions, who endured constant uncertainty, occasional discomfort, cold, long distances and poor sanitation at almost every stop (thank goodness for storm drains, ladies!). But suitably fortified by endless quantities of momos, noodles, egg fried rice and Lhasa beer, these minor inconveniences were set aside, and all cheerfully completed the tour.
Memory cards full, wallets only half-emptied, and with stories to tell for a lifetime.
Thank you Cadi, Ralph, Carole, Eileen and Chris for your patience, flexibility, good humour, and for your lack of complaints!
Postscript
Having been associated with Exodus Travels between 2005 and 2010, I can wholeheartedly recommend them as a first class trekking company and I can attest to their genuine efforts to help the people of Nepal recover from the awful earthquakes that occurred in April and May of 2015.
If you've enjoyed reading this blog, please consider a donation, however small, to their
charitable appeal.
And, better, consider going to Nepal this Autumn when the trekking season starts again. A good selection of adventures can be found
here.
If you're in any doubt about the tumultuous impact of the earthquakes, have a look at the
US Geological Survey.
3 comments:
Thanks so much for your blog, Colin, written as a true professional. It was a great read and I was able to feel in some small part the highs and the lows, the uncertainty and the triumph that you and the others must have felt in doing what you did. I feel that I was able to closely relate to some of your experiences from having shared the Humla - Limi experience with you three years ago, and I remain so grateful for having been able to do that, albeit often from the back of the horse.
Congratulations to you and all on achieving what you have, and I am certain it will remain a most memorable experience for you all in years to come.
David
Thank you so much for the blog. The information described is handy indeed.
Tibet Travel permits
This is a great bloog
Post a Comment